How to Make a Low Ball Offer in Real Estate

Is the Low-Ball Offer Making a Comeback in Canadian Housing?

Could we see the return of low-ball offers in Canadian housing? This buying tactic almost disappeared during the hot market of recent years. But now, tariffs, inflation, and an unpredictable US Federal Policy, have cooled many markets, shifting them from seller’s markets to more balanced ones—or even tipping them in buyers’ favor.

Trying to make the price work

What Exactly Is a Low-Ball Offer?

A low-ball offer happens when someone trying to buy a home offers less than the asking price. While people often see this negatively—like you’re undervaluing the home or disrespecting the seller—it’s actually a common negotiation strategy in real estate.

People make low-ball offers for different reasons. Some truly believe the asking price is too high and want to pay what they think is fair. Others are just testing to see how flexible the seller might be or how desperate they are to sell. Low-ball offers tend to be more common and expected in certain situations, like during economic downturns or in buyer’s markets.

How to Make Your Low-Ball Offer More Compelling

Making low-ball offers is all about having a good strategy. The stronger your position, the more likely a seller will take you seriously. This means knowing both the market and the home’s background, then crafting an offer that’s intelligent, not just cheap. Here are seven ways to strengthen your position before making a low-ball offer.

Check Recent Similar Home Sales (Comps)

Before making a low-ball offer, you need evidence that it’s reasonable. The best way? Look at comparable homes—properties in the same neighborhood with similar features that sold recently. Pay attention to size, layout, condition, and location. If similar homes sold for much less than asking price, you’ve got a strong case for offering less. Recent sales (ideally from the last 30-90 days) give the clearest picture of the market. If prices are dropping and homes aren’t selling at full price, you have more leverage when negotiating.

Know the Market Trends

Market trends greatly affect whether a seller will even consider a low-ball offer. In a buyer’s market, where there are more homes than buyers, sellers are more likely to negotiate. In contrast, in a seller’s market where homes sell quickly with multiple offers, low-ball offers probably won’t get much attention. A balanced market falls somewhere in between. Look at local patterns: Are homes staying on the market longer? Are sellers cutting prices? If yes, your chances of successful negotiation are much better.

Research the Home’s Listing History

To get the best response to your low-ball offer, understand the property’s listing history. It reveals a lot about the seller’s mindset. Has the property been overpriced and had multiple price reductions? Has it been sitting unsold for months? These are signs the seller might be getting anxious, giving you an edge. Also check if the home was previously under contract but the deal fell through. This could mean the seller is eager to close quickly. These signals strengthen your argument for making a low-ball offer.

Get Pre-Approved for Financing

Sellers want assurance a deal won’t collapse at the last minute. Getting pre-approved for a mortgage before making an offer shows you’re a serious buyer who can actually afford the home. This gives you an advantage, especially if competing against less certain offers. It also makes negotiations smoother since the seller doesn’t have to worry about financing delays. Even with a low-ball offer, a pre-approved buyer might have an edge over a higher bid with uncertain financing.

Offer More Than Just a Lower Price

Price isn’t everything in a deal. When making a low-ball offer, try enhancing it in other ways. Offering a quick closing could appeal to a seller wanting to move fast. Being flexible with move-out dates might make your offer stand out if they need extra time. Reducing contingencies, like waiving minor repair requests, can also help. The fewer hassles for the seller, the more likely they’ll consider your low-ball offer, even if it’s below their expectations.

Save those shekles

Work With an Experienced Real Estate Agent

A good real estate agent can be the difference between getting a deal and being ignored. They know how to handle negotiations, find the right comps, and craft an offer that won’t immediately alienate the seller. An experienced agent also knows how to communicate effectively with the listing agent, which helps in understanding what the seller truly wants. If negotiations stall, they can help adjust your offer or find creative solutions without significantly raising the price. Having an expert who understands both the market and negotiation tactics significantly improves your chances.

Be Ready to Walk Away

One of your strongest negotiation tools is willingness to walk away. If a seller won’t budge and their price doesn’t match the market or your budget, it’s fine to move on. Desperation weakens your position, while patience often leads to better opportunities. Sometimes, when a seller realizes you’re willing to walk away, they’ll reconsider and come back with a counteroffer. If not, other homes are always available. Remember, sometimes the smartest move is looking elsewhere for a better deal. The key is knowing when to push harder and when to step back.

A low-ball offer isn’t just about paying less—it’s about making a strategic move based on research and understanding seller psychology. The answer to “Can you low-ball a house offer?” is yes—but only if you do it right. Go in prepared, negotiate wisely, and you might get a home at a price that works for you.

Pros and Cons of Making a Low-Ball Offer

The Benefits:

Potential SavingsThe most obvious advantage is possibly getting a property well below market value. In some cases, a low-ball offer can lead to significant financial gains.

Negotiation Starting PointA low-ball offer can kick-start negotiations. Even if the seller rejects your initial bid, they might counter with something still below asking price, giving you a better deal.

Testing Seller MotivationMaking a low-ball offer helps gauge how motivated the seller is. If they’re eager to sell, they may be more willing to negotiate, giving you better terms.

The Drawbacks:

Risk of Offending the SellerA low-ball offer might insult the seller so much that they refuse to consider any future offers from you, closing the door on a property you want.

Missing Out on OpportunitiesEspecially in a seller’s market, making a low-ball offer can mean losing the property to another buyer willing to pay closer to asking price.

Financing ComplicationsIf your low-ball offer is accepted, it might create problems with getting a loan. Lenders typically won’t finance more than the property’s appraised value. They might also be suspicious of unusually low prices. You might need an appraisal to secure financing.

When Should You Make a Low-Ball Offer?

Low-ball offers work best in a buyer’s market when there are more homes than buyers and competition isn’t an issue. They’re also common when buying fixer-uppers. Another good time is when dealing with a very motivated seller who cares more about selling quickly than getting top dollar.

While there’s no strict rule for making low-ball offers, certain approaches improve your chances. Above all, trust your real estate agent’s professional opinion on whether to offer a low price and exactly how low to go.

5 Key Considerations When Making a Low-Ball Offer

1. Understand the market when deciding how much to low-ball. In a buyer’s market, you have less competition and more negotiating power. In a seller’s market, homes are in higher demand (often due to more buyers, fewer listings, or both), making successful low bids less likely. Trust market conditions more than the listing price when deciding whether to make a low-ball offer. Your agent has likely done a comparative market analysis showing what similar homes in the area have recently sold for.

2. Consider how long the home has been for sale. How long has the property been listed? If you’ve been house hunting, you’ll notice when a home keeps appearing in your search results. Depending on the seller’s urgency, they might be more likely to accept a low-ball offer as time passes. Maybe market conditions are keeping the home unsold, or perhaps it’s the home’s condition. Including a home inspection in your offer is wise to identify any problems and their repair costs.

3. To make a low-ball offer more attractive, make it clean. When the seller wants a quick sale, removing conditions can sweeten a low-ball offer. The seller already feels they’re compromising on price, so fewer conditions helps. To stay flexible during negotiations, get pre-approved for a mortgage before house hunting. You’ll know your financing is approved and exactly how much you can spend. Removing this condition might help secure a faster sale. But be careful! Having a home inspection before buying is generally recommended.

4. Understand the seller’s situation. Knowing why the seller is moving can inform your buying strategy. Perhaps they’ve already bought another home and need to sell this one to avoid paying two mortgages, property taxes, and utility bills. Maybe they inherited the property and don’t want to keep it. A new baby, new job, or many other factors might create urgency for a quick sale.

5. Be reasonable with how low you go. Don’t risk offending the seller or agent with an unreasonable offer. Every seller wants a fair price, just as every buyer wants a good deal. Don’t waste anyone’s time with an offer you know won’t be accepted. Be fair and have clear reasons for your low-ball offer. It could be market conditions, the home’s condition, location, time on market, or something else entirely.

6. 
   

The success of your low offer depends on several factors, including your strategy, market demand, and how urgently the seller needs to sell. Work with your real estate agent to ensure your approach is considered from every angle.